I love to cook. It probably began with that disaster of cheese, apple and orange in the microwave, but that’s a story for a different day. As much as I love cooking though, I adore going out and enjoying the fruits of other people’s labors. Because I’m lazy like that.
No really, after a rather impromptu lunch out with my husband because graduate school had been killing me and I hadn’t fixed anything for his lunch, we decided we rather enjoy lunching together. It’s so, dare I say it? Romantic. Time out, just us, no kids, picking at each other’s meals and chatting. Or maybe we’re just freaks.
Anyway, we decided that we really like lunch, and have been anxiously looking for another chance to sneak off and eat together, sans offspring. So when I ducked out of the office on Friday, I called him up and collected him for a little day trip, of the legal substance variety.
I’ve been in love with the bakery at La Bonne Bouchée since I was an undergrad fulfilling my foreign language requirement. It was recommended to the class by our native-born French professor who insisted on the deliciousness of the fare. Who am I to argue with a Frenchwoman about food? So more than once, I’ve found an excuse to sneak off to the bakery and pick up a treat to take home. But every time, I’ve eyed the cafe with envy, as diners dug into roast chickens and quiche. This lunch, this date lunch, this was the opportunity I needed.
The cafe itself is quite charming, with about 20 tables inside and another 10 out on the patio. There’s plenty of room to move around, and the decor while simple, is adorable. Fresh flowers, either in vases, or growing in pots, are centered on the table. Ours had some cheerful purple pansies with their velvety petals wide open.
We were seating rather quickly, surprising since the cafe and the bakery were bustling and most of the tables appeared to be occupied. Once seated, we were sadly treated to an overly long wait for our server to make her way to us. I suspected she had just started her shift or been on a break, because I overheard someone else asking her if she was aware she had a table that had been sitting there for a good fifteen minutes. That suspicion was actually dispelled by the time we left. She was just flighty, as we discovered in the course of our lunch.
I ordered the French Onion Gratinée and Jeff took the salad with house dressing. He wasn’t too keen on the soupe du jour, which was a vegetable barley. When these arrived at the table, I was given the vegetable barley soup instead. Not being one to make a fuss, I decided to sample it anyway. The soup was rich and thick with tender barley, flavored with bay, and chock full of onions, carrots, celery and red bell peppers. It was quite delicious, even if it wasn’t what I ordered. The salad was a blend of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes and croutons. The dressing made the salad–a creamy vinegarette with a touch of horseradish. Jeff pronounced it a little tarter than he normally prefers, but still quite tasty. I found the dressing to be the perfect addition to the salad. (What can I say, we sample and compare.) Approximately one spoon from finishing my soup, the server arrived with my French Onion. By this point, there was no way I could possibly eat it and still leave room for the rest of lunch, but she insisted on leaving it. I took a bite, and gave the rest over to my husband who happily consumed it. Without a doubt, it was the richest, most amazing version of the soup I have ever encountered, and I would be ashamed to try to make it at home for Jeff again. The broth was so rich, it looked like gravy under the melted cheese, without being that thick. The onions were melt-in-the-mouth delicious and sweet. I’m glad the soup came after all; I’d be annoyed with missing out on that joy happening in my mouth.
For our main fare, I selected Les Crêpes aux Fruits de Mer et aux Epinards and Jeff chose Le Croque Monsieur. The crêpes were light and stuffed with just the right balance of spinach mixed with crab and shrimp. The tarragon lobster sauce on top was delightful, without overbearing the filling. They were served with lightly buttered asparagus spears and rosemary butternut squash. A few green beans were hiding under the asparagus, and sadly, practically turned to mush when touched with a fork; otherwise, the vegetables were a perfect counterpoint to the dish. It was so filling, I found myself wishing I’d opted for the half-order instead.
Jeff devoured his croque monsieur between instances of “mmm, this is good.” I managed to swipe a taste before it vanished from his plate. The bread had been lightly buttered, was of a soft but not mushy texture, and cut of a sizeable portion. (In other words, don’t ask me how the man managed to walk out when we were done.) There was more than ample béchamel covering the sandwich, which delighted him greatly.
Then came the crowning moment, the selection of desserts. You cannot leave a cafe with a bakery without getting dessert. It’s culinary heresy. But we were both quite full and wouldn’t have been able to full appreciate the pastry bliss if we ate them there. When we ordered, we asked that they be boxed to go; when they arrived, they came on plates. We requested boxes again for our sugary treats, which didn’t seem to embarrass the girl at all. In fact, by all appearances, she’d clean forgotten, like she’d clean forgotten who had ordered what when our meal arrived. Incidentally, we chose the vanilla mille-fuille and the four-flavor cake. We were even kind enough to share them with the children after school, although Jeff wanted to hide them for just us. The four flavor cake was good, but the chocolate and mocha flavors stood out over any of the others, making it taste closer to a two flavor cake with drop-dead amazing buttercream frost. (This is not to say that the cake was bad, just that two flavors dominated. I nearly wept with joy over the happy place the cake took me to.) The napolean’s custard was light and creamy, and very grudgingly shared with my overly eager children.
Overall, we enjoyed our lunch, because the food was do delightfully delicious. The other servers in the restaurant appeared to be competent and capable of performing their job without glitches. We suspect we either caught the airhead of the bunch, or at least caught her on an exceptionally off day. However, the owner was quite pleasant when we paid, and we told him the truth when he asked that we return, and we insisted we would.
Ambiance: ****
Food: *****
Service: ***
Overall: ****